New Jersey: need a party, not pols
Last Thursday, a day after Renee Nicole Good was murdered by ICE in Minneapolis, multiple organizations from North Jersey called for a demonstration in downtown Newark. A couple of comrades from Progressive Labor Party (PLP) decided to show up and meet some friends there.
At the rally, organizers began speaking on a blowhorn, one after the other. They were saying all the right zingers. “Look at what the government is doing…capitalism this…imperialism that…we are with Venezuela,” etc. Definitely sharing some sincere anger and calling out the terror of the U.S. as a nation and even general calls for organizing in our communities. I was intimidated until I heard a young Afro-Latina with an incredible ability to inspire and fire up the anger of the working class describing the horrors of capitalism.
I asked myself as I often do when I go with PLP comrades and friends to mass protests, what is the difference between the ideas of the leadership of this protest and the ideas of PLP? For all the electrifying anger that this young woman had, she and none of the other speakers could bring themselves to say that both Democrats and Republicans are deadly to our class. None of these organizers attacked the Democrats as the ground-layers for these open fascist Republicans. None of them can confidently say that there’s no such thing as a good politician under a system that requires racist terror. All the ceasefire votes across city councils didn’t stop the genocide. And it was Democrat Joe Biden who violated the law in NJ that paved the way to re-open Delaney Hall Detention Center which recently also murdered Jean Wilson Brutus, a Haitian immigrant.
I ended up processing these thoughts with a former coworker, who I’ve shared about PLP over the years, and who approached me when he spotted me at the protest. I told him I didn’t feel confident initially about what we should do in these protests as comrades from PLP. But then I shared about the guiding light I finally recognized, the distinction I noticed between the speakers and PLP’s political line on politicians.
He responded that he too was lacking in confidence in terms of what to do, but he seemed hopeful in responding to the alternative I suggested: the revolutionary strategy of building an organization within the working class to get rid of capitalism instead of wasting our time on politicians, all who will ultimately betray us.
He also shared that his internal struggle to become a part of such a goal is intensifying within him given the sharpening dangers faced by our class currently. He expressed that there are a lot of things that need to be figured out regarding such a project. Additionally, he mentioned that what he is mainly confronting and working through is his perception that joining a group, perhaps like PLP, feels like a form of submitting to authority.
I responded to this by referencing the need to make decisions collectively and having the collective discipline to stick to them to defeat the capitalist system, in other words using democratic centralism, to build that organization our class needs. To this he responded by commenting on genuinely wanting to understand better what is meant by “democratic centralism.” To which I directed him to the 1982 article “On Democratic Centralism”on PLP.org.
After the protest, us comrades went home together. We collectively affirmed the need to dig deeper into our relationships with workers in the mass organizations around us to build our confidence and a broader communist base. Such experience will encourage us to turn moments of fightback into schools for communism alongside masses of workers. We even brainstormed creating a “know your communist chants” card that we can distribute to people at protests.
*****
Smash ICE now!
After going with members of a Resistance network to a local mall (CHALLENGE letter 12/24/2025), we joined the celebration of the first anniversary of the network with 60 folks attending. The network had done amazing activities throughout the year in addition to maintaining a chat informing members of multiple struggles in the area. On the ground activities have included talking to business owners to press for “No ICE” posters in their windows, trailing ICE and Park police on the federal parkway in the town, and pressing town council members to make sure the local police were not helping ICE. Waving banners over the federal parkway overpass was diligently staffed every week. The Community Center has Know Your Rights cards in over 40 languages. Members took the cards and passed them out to workers and neighbors. There were at least four marches and rallies from April – October. When the organizer asked for suggestions for more activities, a young man said going door to door to the apartment buildings behind the mall would be a good idea to diversify the membership. Everything cannot be done virtually!
As one of the organizations active in the network, PLP had a table along with other fightback organizations including several that we have been working with over the past few months. PLP’s two minute speech emphasized internationalism vs nationalism, multiracial unity, working in transit (Metro) and our communities and the necessity for a violent revolution to overthrow capitalism. Six comrades helped at our table which highlighted our work against genocide in Gaza and our campaign against ICE in Metro. We had postcards that show that METRO, the bus and subway system, was still showing recruitment ads for the Customs and Border Patrol on the sides of the buses and in subway stations and train cars.
This past summer we mailed 130 postcards and spoke at the Metro Board meeting on this issue. Ten people signed postcards today, four folks signed up for more information and attendees from the other groups took CHALLENGE, impressed that we are a national organization. We also helped at the table with the students from the Philippines who called for the release of Chantal, a former student working in Mindoro. She is being held by the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) and must be returned to the U.S. Going forward one comrade freed up their schedule to be able to regularly attend bi-weekly planning meetings.
Next steps for the Party include follow up and recruitment of the organizers at the celebration and sharper attacks on Metro for working closely with ICE through their transit police and advertising policies. Putting our line on multiracial unity into practice in this neighborhood will strengthen the fight against ICE and fascism.
*****
North Carolina: Protests grow, need communist politics
Over 1,000 workers took to the streets on Saturday, in Durham, North Carolina in protest over the fascist murder of Renee Good by Trump’s ICE Gestapo. Shocked by Renee Good’s murder, the Raleigh-Durham metro area organized a protest march in Bull Park in downtown Durham. Workers marched eight blocks to Durham Central Park. The multiracial march consisted of many workers and students from nearby Duke University. While inspiring to see working class anger, the protest had ideological weaknesses. It was organized by a liberal democratic organization. The organizers gave a speech not mentioning racism nor the class nature of fascism at home. No connection was made to the imperialist attack on Venezuela by U.S. bosses. It was disconnected, reformist, and made no mention of communist revolution. Despite the bad politics, there was a Progressive Labor Party (PLP) presence as copies of CHALLENGE were distributed along the march route to workers. U.S. capitalism has morphed into fascism, and no phony leftist politics will rescue the working class. The only way out is a disciplined worker-led communist revolution by the PLP.
On Sunday, Jan. 11th, the Raleigh ICE protest was smaller, and not as well organized as the Durham protest against fascist ICE killers who murdered Renee Good. There were 200 protesters on both sides of North Highway 1 in Raleigh. The weaknesses were having U.S. military flags there. Those are imperialist symbols, as the U.S. military attacked Venezuela, so they had no place at an anti ICE protest. Workers at the protest understood that Renee Good’s murder was an act of fascism, but all branches of the U.S. government are tied to fascism. We distributed CHALLENGE and leaflets discussing the U.S. bosses’ Venezuela attack.
The staff at the Raleigh bookstore in the liberal Hillsborough neighborhood were glad to get the CHALLENGE and party leaflets. They put everything on a display table for patrons to help themselves.
We plan to attend additional rallies and protests and keep in contact with the bookstore.
*****
Need communist theory to make revolution
I want to share some advice from an international communist that challenged me to reflect. They suggested that I read all 46 volumes of Lenin’s collected works. At first I was taken aback at this suggestion. In the revolutionary scene in the U.S. there is considerable controversy whether it is necessary to read theory at all. But then I remembered that in the cultural revolution, it was the increasingly productive forces über alles right wing of the Communist Party of China (Deng Xiao Ping and Liu Shao Qi) that insisted against reading theory. They said taking part in the daily life of a revolution was enough. If any theory was necessary Mao Ze Dong was enough. The left wing insisted that it was necessary not only to read Mao but Lenin and Marx as well.
In our vacillations, I maintain that the most important element is not just reading the text but organizing the information and then applying it in practice. I hope to produce some kind of outline or guide to Lenin’s work as an exercise and example for others to inspire them to investigate themselves. It is possible to read a summary of the main events, but given that Lenin’s writing is freely available, challenging yourself to go through the text and organize the information is a worthy exercise. My friend maintains that the most important thing is to organize a study group among the working class, read as many of the 46 volumes of Lenin’s collected works as possible (one volume intimidates me). He says that one worker with little formal education has read the entire 46 volumes over the course of a few years. This worker reported their worldview and self-image transformed by the process of reading and discussing Lenin. Then those who have been transformed and recognize the power of the writing will become study group leaders, multiplying the numbers of revolutionary workers organically. I hope to write again soon with more stories from this adventure!
*****
State exam enforces bosses’ fascist agenda
The recent January English Regents was a clear example of how education can be used to help the ruling class develop fascism. In order to graduate from high school in New York State, students must complete this test. There are two essays on the test: basically, an argumentative and thematic essay. The argumentative essay’s topic was to have students argue whether or not employers should be allowed to scour social media for their prospective employees. As several of my coworkers pointed out, it forced the students to have to use the bosses’ lens.
In the current era of rampant ICE sweeps and the use of social media to attack and round up workers, this essay’s supporting texts never mentioned that corporations such as Palantir are helping the modern Gestapo in their attacks on the working class. The texts also never mentioned that Trump and DOGE’s recent attacks on the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) have weakened even those meager defenses.
We can expect to see more curriculum and testing designed to force the bosses’ lens on our students.
Just as the recent Homeland Security threat assessment clearly shows, the bosses are worried about “class-based or economic grievances” within the working class. They know they have nothing to offer our class but more wars, exploitation, and the divisive ideologies of racism and sexism. Regardless of whether or not we win a few more crumbs through reform now, it doesn’t mean that we won’t be seeing the sharpening contradictions of the falling rate of profit and imperialism making revolution more and more of a necessity.
The purpose of the essay was to reinforce the myth of “Americana” as the basis for U.S. patriotism. For liberal fascism to occur, it needs to create the lie that there is a national identity. The U.S. was formed through the genocide of its indigenous people groups and the enslavement of Black workers while super exploiting white workers.
Bringing back patriotism while Modern Manifest Destiny reinforces the contemporary Monroe Doctrine of U.S. imperialism reasserting their domination in South America is a fundamental necessity to the U.S. ruling class. As the crisis of capitalism continues to intensify, teachers should expect to see more mandated curriculums, more tests clearly focused on promoting capitalist ideology and subjugation to the new AI surveillance machine, and more passages determined to promote the myth of Americana. It is important that we view these moments as opportunities to discuss with our coworkers as we try to get them to understand the world and invite them to Party events.
*****
Protests spread across U.S. against ICE terror
The Guardian, 1/24–Large protests spread across US cities on Saturday – including Minneapolis, New York City, San Francisco, Boston and Providence, Rhode Island – after 37-year-old Alex Pretti, a registered nurse living in Minneapolis, was shot dead by federal agents…just one day after thousands marched through the streets of Minneapolis to protest against…ICE…Thousands more rallied in Union Square in New York City…In Washington DC, a giant crowd formed...Across the country in San Francisco, hundreds of people gathered in the city’s downtown as the sun began to set… further south, hundreds of people took to the streets of downtown Los Angeles…In Providence, hundreds showed up to protest…
Racist capitalist economics still at work
CEPR, 1/14–In 2025, Black America needed about 1.8 million more people working to have the same employment rates (employment-to-population ratios) as White America (Table 1). This Black jobs deficit cost Black America about $87 billion in lost income…Researchers continue to find strong evidence of anti-Black bias in hiring. Even among the formerly incarcerated, White individuals are more likely to find employment than Black individuals. Persistent racial discrimination in the labor market can lead Black individuals to become discouraged and not actively attempt to find work…
Iran economy and rulers at risk of collapse
Foreign Affairs, 1/13–the Islamic Republic appears more fragile than ever after last June’s 12-day war. The regime seems incapable of addressing the root causes of the economic crisis that has driven its people to the streets…food prices overall have jumped by 72 percent since January 2025. An Iranian government spokesman warned that they could rise by another 20 to 30 percent in the coming weeks…Tehran…has instructed that free-market prices should prevail…Educated youth and professionals have been hit especially hard…Major rivers supplying Isfahan and Shiraz with water now routinely run dry, and Tehran is running out of water.
Israeli settlers destroy and replace Palestinian villagers
Al Jazeera, 1/22–... the Israeli settlers’ celebrations have finished for the day. But the village of Ras Ein al-Auja, situated in the eastern West Bank’s Jericho governorate, has been all but wiped out. The village was one of the last Palestinian herding communities in this part of the Jordan Valley, but now, the herders’ sheep have gone – most of them stolen or poisoned by settlers or sold off by villagers under pressure. Their water has been cut off – the Ras Ein spring declared off-limits by the neighbouring settlers for the past year…This…marks the largest expulsion from a single Bedouin community as a result of Israeli settler violence in modern times...
Farmers suffer through overproduction crisis
New York Times, 1/25–“What am I supposed to do with 2.2 million pounds of rice?”...raising his voice…over the noisy industrial fans drying the rice on his farm in Merigold, Miss…Across the country, farmers are struggling. Prices for nearly every major crop are below what it costs to grow them…a group representing farmers, participants floated the idea of a government program that would pay producers to destroy the harvested rice sitting in their bins. A similar program was put in place during the 1980s farm crisis, when the Agriculture Department paid farmers to idle land and reduce huge surpluses of crops…India, the world’s largest producer of rice… [is] flooding the world with rice.
Nigerian workers at risk of starvation
ABC News, 1/22–The U.N. World Food Program said Tuesday that more than a million people in northeastern Nigeria could lose access to emergency food and nutrition aid within weeks unless funding is secured, as violence and hunger surge in the region…The food agency of the United Nations said in a statement it will sharply scale back assistance, limiting it to only 72,000 people in February, down from 1.3 million assisted during last year’s lean season, which runs from May to October…35 million people are likely to experience severe hunger in Nigeria this year, the highest figure on the continent and the largest recorded since the agency began collecting data in the country.
- Information
Editorial: Desperate empire - Venezuela, U.S. decline & war
- Information
- 16 January 2026 501 hits
The kidnapping of Venezuela President Nicolás Maduro marks an acceleration of U.S. decline and a decisive break from its own the liberal world order. As imperialist China, Russia, and the U.S. hurtle toward wider war, the world is growing more volatile and dangerous by the day.
To smash imperialism, the working class needs a communist movement. Progressive Labor Party strives to be that force, but we need you to join the fight.
Venezuela: rivalry flashpoint
Hugo Chávez’s 1999 Bolivarian “Revolution” ran on Venezuela’s vast reserves of oil, not working-class power. Following the death of Chávez, Maduro oversaw a drastic decline of living conditions for tens of millions of workers. Venezuela’s state capitalists enriched themselves while distributing crumbs to workers. The Chavistas used U.S. sanctions to obscure their own theft while millions were starved and displaced. As of last year, 60 percent of workers struggled to afford food and 80 percent were underemployed or unemployed (New York Times, 1/8). Workers always pay the price for bosses’ fights, whether local or global. That is why we must reject nationalism in all its forms.
Venezuela is caught in the sharpening inter-imperialist rivalry among the U.S., China, and Russia. For the U.S., Maduro’s great crime wasn’t narcoterrorism—it was that he was cutting deals with the enemy. The U.S. rulers found an opportunistic section of the Venezuelan ruling class apparently willing to be bought off: “The whole operation looked so easy that many analysts…wondered whether regime insiders abetted Maduro’s extraction, in effect staging a palace coup by proxy” (FA, 1/7).
Venezuela is strategically located and holds the world’s largest proven oil reserves: 303 billion barrels, or 17 percent of the global total (Institute for Energy Research, 1/13). Over the last 20 years, the historic U.S “backyard” of Latin America, rooted in the 1823 Monroe Doctrine, has been steadily infiltrated by a rival imperialist. China has “economically displaced” the U.S. in “10 out of 12 countries in South America,” with more trade, investment, and development financing (NYT, 1/9). China’s banks have loaned billions in exchange for oil and minerals while its companies build ports, mines, and infrastructure. By 2024, most of Venezuela’s crude oil was flowing to China, though it amounted to only 4 percent of China’s total oil imports. What’s at stake here isn’t Chinese survival, but U.S. regional dominance.
China’s limited verbal condemnation of the U.S. invasion shows that China’s rulers aren’t yet ready for a direct military confrontation, especially as they manage friction with Taiwan and an economic slowdown. Russia’s muted response might signal its satisfaction with the U.S. bulldozing of NATO and its limited backing of Ukraine. As there is no honor among thieves, these alliances will continue to shift. The world is unstable because capitalists are legitimized gangsters who fight tooth and nail for profits as they exploit our class. The ultimate and inevitable expression of their competition is world war.
Competing visions of U.S. power
For seven decades, U.S. imperialism relied on international institutions that enabled its bosses to control the rules of the game: NATO, the United Nations, the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank. These organizations normalized a “rules-based” liberal world order that consolidated U.S. dominance after World War II. But make no mistake—their dominance was a bloody one! From 1945 to 2023, the U.S. launched at least 255 military operations (Congress, 6/7/23).
Because capitalist competition inevitably leads to rise and fall of empires, the old order began fraying in the 1970s, marked by the U.S. defeat in Vietnam. More recently, China’s rise has weakened U.S. leverage globally. State Terrorist-in-Chief Donald Trump’s response has been to wreck the old world order and move toward a Fortress America that would control Latin America while abandoning multilateral commitments in Europe and Asia.
While some might see the theatrics of kidnapping a president as a show of strength, it is anything but. As U.S. dominance wanes, the bosses’ tactics to preserve it become even more desperate and rabid.
The U.S. ruling class is split into two main competing factions. The Big Fascists of finance capital still seek global domination through endless war. But the domestically oriented Small Fascists behind Trump have no interest in spending their profits on far-flung ground wars. They accept that U.S. global dominance is slipping and are focused on locking down a sphere of influence in the Americas, hence the belligerent operation in Venezuela. Conceding Ukraine to Russia and Taiwan to China would seem to align with this strategy. But Trump’s raw coercion could have unintended consequences by emboldening other capitalists to do the same. Case in point: China’s 10-hour live-firing drills to rehearse a blockade of Taiwan. As CHALLENGE goes to press, meanwhile, threats of U.S. military action in Iran are escalating.
How the next world war unfolds remains uncertain. What’s clear is we live in perilous times. Within that danger also lies Progressive Labor Party’s responsibility to turn world war into class war.
We need communism
State terror is the order of the day. The display of brute force in Venezuela, which killed 80 people on the ground, is a harbinger of fascism, driven by U.S. decline and by bitter splits in the ruling class. So are the brazen murders of Black and white workers, from Keith Porter in Los Angeles to Renee Good in Minneapolis, by the modern slave-catchers known as ICE (see page 1). These incidents of callous violence expose the bosses’ raw dictatorship under their slipping democratic mask.
The capitalists know that the international working class is the mortal threat to their profits and survival. But the only way we can realize our revolutionary potential is by building a mass workers’ party. Amid the chaos of capitalism, there can be no return to a safer, more stable time.
There are no good capitalist bosses, no lesser evils–not in the U.S. or China, not in Russia or Venezuela. From Russia to China to Vietnam, the only force that has ever defeated an “unbeatable” bosses’ empire is a mass communist-led movement. And it was only the communist leadership of the USSR that defeated the German Nazi war machine.
There is no middle path. The time to organize was yesterday. We cannot appease or wish away fascism and world war. We need to build an international communist party that can smash imperialist war for all time–and create a new world that serves workers’ needs. Fight for communism! Join Progressive Labor Party!
U.S. Hypocrisy
Laws are made by and for the ruling class. While liberal U.S. bosses act appalled at the “illegal” seizure of Venezuela’s president and oil, the rules of U.S. democracy have been a longtime cover for the invasion and overthrow or regimes that failed to roll over to serve U.S. capitalist interests. What’s different today is the capitalist rulers’ open shamelessness. Here are just a few past examples:
- Iran (1953): A CIA-led coup ousted the elected government after it nationalized the country’s oil industry, and reinstalled a monarchy in league with the U.S.
- Chile (1973): After Cuba-aligned President Salvador Allende nationalized the copper industy, the U.S. launched a coup that killed Allende and established a brutal 17-year dictatorship under Augusto Pinochet.
- Panama (1989): Citing drug trafficking and the killing of a Marine, the U.S. invaded the country and captured and jailed military ruler Manuel Noriega. The real goal was to secure control over the Panama Canal, a critical passageway for global supply chains.
- Iraq (1990-1991, 2003-2011): With various phony pretexts, including non-existent “weapons of mass destruction,” the U.S. waged two wars to control vast oil reserves in Iraq and Kuwait–and it destroyed as many as one million lives in the process.
LOS ANGELES, CA, January 12—Twenty-five students and workers from Progressive Labor Party (PLP) and friends of the Party came together for a powerful rally that brought a clear, uncompromising message to the community: capitalism offers nothing to our class but war, fascism, and death, and only communist revolution can create a world that serves the needs of working people.
Everything is connected
We held this rally in a neighborhood where the violence of the capitalist state is not abstract. This is the same community where Alex Flores was murdered by the Los Angeles Police Department, and where members of Progressive Labor Party (PLP) have been organizing since 2019 alongside residents, students, and workers to fight police terror and build a fighting party. Holding the rally here was intentional. The fight against imperialist war abroad and racist police murder and attacks on immigrant workers at home is one struggle. The community particularly loved our chant “La Migra, la policía, la misma porqueria.”
At the rally, a half dozen young comrades and friends led chants and gave speeches. They reminded the neighborhood that they are not alone, that we are here to fight alongside them against racist terror in all its forms. One young Latin woman worker spoke passionately about how demoralizing it is to wake up to the daily horrors of capitalism, each day worse than the last, but that she was confident that we can come together in the fight for communism, the world the working class deserves.
Capitalism is violence
A PLP member delivered a speech connecting U.S. aggression against Venezuela with the murder of a protester by ICE agents in Minneapolis. The speech laid bare the priorities of this system: there is “no money” for health care, schools, or housing, but unlimited funding for police, ICE, drones, and military intervention. From Latin America to Los Angeles, capitalism defends profit and empire through violence.
The message resonated. Neighbors stopped to listen, nodded in agreement, and joined conversations about why these atrocities are not accidents, but the predictable outcomes of a system built on exploitation. Many took copies of CHALLENGE, asked questions about Progressive Labor Party, and shared their own experiences with police harassment, low wages, and struggling to survive while the rich got richer. The taco restaurant across from where we rallied even brought us free licuados for all participants in the rally as a show of support for our message
Throughout the rally, we emphasized a central truth: workers create all the wealth in society and therefore have the power to change it. We do not need bosses, landlords, cops, or generals. But this system cannot exist without our labor. When we organize together—across race, nationality, and borders—we become an unstoppable force.
The strong response from the community showed that people are hungry for a revolutionary explanation and a revolutionary solution. Reform has failed. Voting has failed. Appeals to “justice” from a brutal system have failed. What working people need is organization, solidarity, and communist leadership.
This rally was one small but important step in building that movement. We will continue organizing in this neighborhood, distributing CHALLENGE standing with families impacted by police terror, and fighting to unite workers and students against imperialism, fascism, and capitalism itself.
The future belongs to the working class—but only if we organize to take it.
Fight back! Organize! Build communism!
- Information
We need mass class struggle, not vigilante violence
- Information
- 16 January 2026 507 hits
On December 31st, 2025, Keith Porter, a 43-year-old father of two in Los Angeles, was shot three times and ruthlessly murdered by an off-duty ICE agent. His “crime”? Being Black. Being alive. Owning a rifle. Celebrating the New Year.
A week later, on January 7th, nearly two thousand miles away in Minneapolis, where ICE had turned the streets into a war zone, Jonathan Ross, another ICE agent, fired three shots into the face of a 37-year-old mother of three Renee Good as she tried to flee an attempted ICE raid. Her “crime”? Defending her Black and Brown neighbors from ICE terror.
These executions, carried out by rabidly racist and sexist, Gestapo-like ICE agents, are becoming the norm under an increasingly fascist U.S. empire. They expose the violent core of capitalism, its state-sponsored terror, and the crisis of its sham democracy. After Renee’s killing, her grieving wife said it plainly: “We had whistles, but they had guns.” Her words reveal the lie that this system, built on violence, can be dismantled with non-violence, especially as fascism sharpens its claws.
Violence and terror are not accidents, they are capitalism’s lifeblood. And as outrage spreads, workers feel the urge to strike back, to deliver vengeance against the state and the capitalists who uphold it. Vigilantism—the belief that individuals can balance the scales of justice with violence is no longer marginal; it is gaining mass appeal and provoking state repression.
Millions cheered when Luigi Mangione killed the United Healthcare CEO in late 2024, yet premiums soared, and Trump’s $30 billion “Big Beautiful” heist funneled funds from healthcare to finance ICE raids carried out by would-be Nazi assassins, like the one who murdered Good. Tyler Robinson murdered MAGA influencer Charlie Kirk live as Kirk was about to utter racist words about Black lives. In a copycat-style killing, Robinson, reportedly in a relationship with his transgender roommate, engraved Catch Fascist and Bella Ciao on the bullet casings.
Kirk’s death was weaponized by Trump and his fascist acolytes, rallying their racist and sexist base, labeling Antifa domestic terrorists, and threatening anyone who spoke out. These acts of violence only begot more violence and repression. The killings of Kirk and the healthcare CEO are not anomalies—they are the inevitable outcome of a system that promotes pacifism while normalizing horror, fetishizing individual heroes, and breeding cynicism about collective struggle, keeping us weak and divided.
The dead end of vigilantism in a failing system
As U.S. domination over global capitalist markets faces competition from Russian and Chinese bosses, workers feel the squeeze. Finance capital’s drive for profit inevitably rolls back the gains workers have fought and died for. Capitalism’s pathologies can only be solved by building a mass communist party; there are no quick fixes to the attacks on the working class.
From Superman to Batman to Paw Patrol, vigilante icons teach workers from infancy to valorize individualism over collective action. No matter the superhero, their role in capitalist propaganda is to “save the day” because the masses are supposedly too weak to save themselves. Many cheered Luigi Mangione’s assassination of the United Healthcare CEO a year ago, but killing one CEO did nothing to challenge the parasitic nature of health insurance—a finance capitalist system that extracts far more than it returns. Premiums have soared. Attacks on healthcare and social services have intensified globally, as bosses, under pressure from military buildup and capitalist competition, cut back gains workers have literally died to achieve.
John Brown set it off, but the masses abolished slavery
Much like the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution in China, the abolitionist movement and Civil War in the United States, including the militant actions of John Brown, point to important lessons around the necessity for multiracial, collective action to secure long-term gains for the working class. The militant abolitionist John Brown, with a small band of fearless freedom fighters against slavery, orchestrated a raid on the U.S. military arsenal at Harper’s Ferry in 1859, undoubtedly escalating the decline of the racist system of chattel slavery in the country and triggering more quickly what would become the Civil War. But it took the concerted effort of an organized military force and the death of 600,000 soldiers, black and white, to bring about the end of that retrograde, backward mode of production. The main lesson about Nat Turner, John Brown, Harriet Tubman and the dozens of other brave souls who stood up militantly for the overthrow of slavery, is that their efforts could not be realized until the movement became fully mass in political scope and was backed by an army.
Conclusion: Confidence in the working class is key
Progressive Labor Party (PLP) condemns vigilante violence in any form. As one worker said astutely, “when many voices become one for political power in the right direction we can make change.” Communists believe that the right direction is not voting, not adding more Black and brown or “left” politicians to office, and certainly not assassinations, bombings or other acts of adventurism. We must eliminate production of resources for profit. Hundreds of students from Columbia University and beyond faced jail time and expulsion from college in the name of fighting imperialist genocide in 2023. They followed the lead of countless doctors and journalists across Gaza who worked in conditions of utter terror as bombs reigned down over them to save the lives of unarmed workers–mainly children–and reveal these atrocities to the world. Millions of workers have turned out in Italy in the past few months in general strikes to protest the relentless cutbacks in wages and social services as bosses divert funds for military buildup and eventual war. And let’s not forget the hundreds of thousands of workers who poured into the streets all over the world during the Covid-19 outbreak against the George Floyd racist police assassination, as millions more were left at the peril of a deadly virus that the bosses chose not to contain for months and months.
These masses are the heroes of our class. But in spite of all of these heroic deeds, the genocide against workers in Palestine rages, and workers across Italy and worldwide continue to face austerity cutbacks. Each struggle teaches our class new lessons about the limits of reforming capitalism, but we need an organized party that is leading these struggles and fighting for more than just militant reforms. Progressive Labor Party is not a savior to the working class. We do not call for workers to grab guns and shoot any boss they see–or their traitorous thugs in blue or camouflage. But we do understand that armed workers, backed by a revolutionary military of soldiers and officers, led by our party, is a fundamental ingredient for our class to free itself from the grips of this current system and establish something exponentially smarter, healthier and better for the human race. And this collective process is the ultimate heroism.
